What to make of it all:
*Brown and his Gold Cartel allies have succeeded in casting a pall over the gold market which may last for months. Veteran gold market observers all know what happened to the price of gold when Britain announced their sales in 1999 and when Australia bombed the market in 1997.
*What is coming out from the G-7 meeting is for public consumption. The real story is a very different one. The only aspect which is transparent is Brown pushing for sales to keep the price of gold capped for the foreseeable future.
*It is inconceivable how the South African finance minister said what he did, except to understand the man is bought and paid for and yes, a traitor to his people and the poor of his country. South African gold companies are laying off workers and delaying plans to hire more miners because they cannot make enough profit at these gold price levels with their costs having risen so sharply. Lower gold prices for years to come will be devastating.
Perhaps Manuel really is stupid, yet a nincompoop would know that even talk of outright gold sales would put a damper on the price and scare away potential investors – at least western investors – which would adversely affect the price. Since a lowered gold price hurts so many people in South Africa and sub-Saharan Africa, he should have lowered the boom on Brown, not facilitate his proposal.
This will give you some idea of how powerful The Gold Cartel and the powers behind them really are. Manuel’s moronic comments were blunt. Where were Canada’s and Australia’s finance ministers when they were talked into selling their gold? Think of how the lowered gold price has affected so many companies in Canada and Australia over the past half decade – the lowered economic activity, etc. There is no doubt in my mind the price of gold will soar above $1,000+ per ounce in the years to come, IMF sales or no. The governments of Canada and Australia will not participate as both countries have dumped ALL their gold.
*No country is more anti-gold than the US. GATA has 6 years of documentation of this. Therefore, you can be sure U.S. Treasury Under Secretary John Taylor’s objection to gold sales is a red herring of sorts. While speculation on my part, there is good reason to believe the US is scared to death of the gold issue being raised, as it may lead to questions about US gold, a portion of which has most likely been clandestinely mobilized (lend or swapped out). The last thing the US wants is for this issue to become a highly discussed one in our country. This would be just the opportunity for GATA to bring up the hard questions re US gold, a nightmare for the US Treasury, Fed, certain members of Congress etc.
How interesting that Treasury Secretary Snow developed a cold right after the State of the Union Address on Wednesday and the G-7 meeting on Friday. Did he fear pointed questions regarding gold and perhaps the role of the Exchange Stabilization Fund these days in capping the gold price?
*Now for the potential good news. It is the general notion in the GATA camp that The Gold Cartel is running low on enough physical gold to keep the price from moving MUCH higher. This has been my take for months. Now, we have Gold Cartel apologist Brown demoralizing the gold market with his calls for outright IMF sales. Let us go retro:
There was a clamor to sell IMF Gold in 1999, which was roundly defeated, with support for the measure coming mostly from the US Treasury. Britain announced their sale program only after this measure was defeated, just as gold was finally about to take out $300 per ounce on the upside. The point is The Gold Cartel was scrambling for gold back then to cap the price and England came to their rescue. Here we are six years later and they appear to be in a similar situation, with one immense difference. The Gold Cartel has gone though 6,000 to 10,000 tonnes of central bank gold since then. One fifth to one third of central bank gold has been used up, bought by the Chinese, Arabs, Turks, Indians, etc. Wherever The Gold Cartel found their gold over these past years, it is gone.
The only question is who is out the gold? The British? Could they be short? The US? Is our "Deep Storage" Treasury gold really gold which is yet to be mined because we have lent out, or swapped out, most of our gold? Does the US have some kind of tacit agreement with the likes of Barrick, etc., to replace this gold down the road if they feel they are going to be found out? Hard to know...all of these notions are very plausible.
What GATA does know is some of the above is the way it is. The only question is exactly who are the culprits and when will they be found out. Since there is a 1500+ tonne yearly supply/demand deficit, discovery is only a matter of time. Therefore, while The Gold Cartel and allies have sullied the very short-term, the big picture grows even brighter.
Yes, it is very plausible The Gold Cartel is truly hitting the fan and knows the jig is up, gradually coming to the end of the decade-long scheme as they know they don’t have the gold to keep up their scam. It is conceivable they are using this opportunity to do what they can to rout the market and turn the specs short. Why? Because they need to buy all the gold they can down here to cover some undisclosed predicaments (England covering shorts, for example). Not only talking about countries here. This is the chance for JP Morgan Chase and Goldman Sachs to continue to cover too. They might not get a better one for decades to come.
Meanwhile, it is amazing how gullible certain in the mainstream are when it comes to what Wall Street and officialdom puts out there. None is more visibly gullible than Denis Gartman, of the widely-followed Gartman Letter. His latest today on the G-7/IMF flap:
The gold bulls got a reprieve over the weekend when it was decided at the G-7 meeting to defer any action on the plan put forth by UK Chancellor of the Exchequer Brown to tackle the problems of Third World debt and aid by selling gold from the IMF's reserves... or from the reserves of the various industrialised nations. In the communiqué released at the meeting's end, the leaders said only that they would take up the discussion at a later date... perhaps in April in Washington and/or perhaps in the UK in June Mr. Rodrigo Rato, the IMF's Managing Director, has been given the portfolio to look into the matter of such gold sales and/or reserve re-valuation and to make his case at the April meeting. The IMF has 3,217 tonnes of gold in store, valued at approximately 20% of its current spot price and the most likely proposal that he will put forth shall be to revalue that gold, strengthen the IMF's balance sheet, and use that stronger balance sheet either to borrow against, with the proceeds going to the Third World, or actually selling the told in question and using those very real proceeds to pay down that same debt.
For the moment, however, the proposition has been tabled and put into Mr. Rato's hands for later consideration. The US led the opposition to Mr. Brown's proposals, and was rather openly critical of his proposal to use national and/or IMF gold reserves in some fashion for the aid he hoped to put forth. We are left to wonder how our friends at GATA, who are so convinced that the US has lead a conspiracy to keep gold prices down, shall view the US opposition to gold sales this time now. It leaves GATA in a bit of a quandary, for suddenly the governments are not their enemy but are instead their aid and comfort..
-END-