Good stuff from Kiwi Land:
Hi Bill :
I decided to play with numbers today just to see how bad things really were with the Gold shares. I selected a number of well known names listed them above with their gains (mostly substantial losses) for the year. Some of the prices I quoted are in CDN Dollars, others in US Dollars. There are not many Gold shares that are up for the year. Just a couple of mine. With Silver the story is mixed. Western Silver has a large gain but that is a company specific story. However I did notice one thing. Look at Coeur d”Alene and Hecla. Both down 30%, far worse than the competition and these are the only two silver shares in the HUI index. Is someone playing games with the Index Components?
[Blockierte Grafik: http://www.lemetropolecafe.com/img2004/StockChart1220.gif]
Here is a comment that I picked off a chat board today: “Gold and gold stock action pathetic today in view of decent drop in the buck.. I suspect gold is headed towards $420 and may even test the $400 area within a few months.” This is a typical reaction from investors closely watching the action.
I’ve read many articles about recent gold share “underperformance” and I’ve come to the conclusion that there is only one answer. Manipulation. Sure there are other influences such as tax loss selling. But this is late in the month for that. Then there are the arguments that Gold isn’t going up in other currencies. True but we faced the same problem last year and that didn’t stop the shares from going up.
Let’s look at it from the other side-the enemy side. They face the difficult problem of defending an overvalued currency with nothing but promises. Promises they’ve repeatedly broken over the decades. Gold has now gone up 75% against the US Dollar over the past 3 years and Gold shares have outperformed most other sectors. If the average investor got it into his head to put just 5% of his assets into Gold/gold shares it would be curtains for the Dollar. The solution? Make sure anyone who tries this gets burned real bad. Perception is everything. For those of us who bought the HUI under 50 or even under 150 the current situation is bearable. But for anyone who bought Gold shares this year for the first time, unless they’re good traders, it has been a very bad year. As the table above clearly shows.
Right now the Gold shares are very very cheap. Gold itself is very very cheap in most foreign currencies. Here in New Zealand, Gold is $100 an oz cheaper now than it was 3 years ago. And yet we see so called Gold bulls actually shorting the gold shares. Calling for Gold to drop to $400 or less. Why? Because they look at Gold share charts rather than fundamentals and their charts are screaming SELL at them. They believe the Gold shares lead the metal.
The bad guys have accomplished this in the same way they have saved the Dow and Nasdaq. Just as their strategic buying has prevented bad charts in these indices their strategic selling of Gold shares has done the opposite to the HUI and other Gold indices. Just as we see the Dow miraculously recover just before close we see the HUI do a swan dive. Bad news on individual Dow shares is bought and good news or a Gold miner is sold. We see this over and over again.
Even long time pros like Veneroso has been tricked by the Gold share action. His recent comments have no doubt scared many others into selling. I take a different view of all this. It’s simple. Just repeat this over and over again:
A tonne of Gold costs $14 Million. A tonne of Gold costs $14 Million. A tonne of Gold costs $14 Million.
And every day, EVERY DAY, the USA is asking the world to hand over $2 to $3 Billion in charity. That’s right in charity never to be repaid except possibly at a steep discount.
That’s the equivalent of 150 tonnes a day! 4500 tonnes a month! 55,000 tonnes a year! They have to convince the world to accept the paper equivalent of 55,000 tonnes of Gold a year in a currency that is falling. You have to hand it to them. So far their trickery has worked. You can fool a lot of people a lot of the time.
The bad guys want to make sure YOU stay in the Dollar. Not in Gold where you’re protected. So they engineer quick run ups in the Gold shares and then, just as a previous resistance level is broken and you would expect further buying to enter the market, just then, they sell the HUI big time. They sell a small cache of Gold “borrowed” from some poor Central Bank and the “suckers” who bought the rally are slaughtered.
If you want to be in Gold shares rather than the Dollar the time to buy is when the shares are down and out. Like now! Guess who else is buying down here?
Cheers from Auckland, Ed
ed.na@xtra.co.nz