Nach Meinung von Prof. Anatal Fekete, Jason Hommel und Reinhard Deutsch haben sich Gold/Silber in einem evolutionären Prozess über Jahrtausende zu Geld entwickelt und diese Funktion bis heute behalten, trotz jahrzehntelanger Demonetisierung in beiden Metallen.
Die Silberexperten Ted Butler und Israel Friedmann hingegen bestreiten, dass Silber (und Gold) heutzutage noch als Geld zu funktionieren in der Lage sind.
"Gold and silver have become money through an evolution as the most marketable goods. In more details, gold is most marketable in the large. This can also be expressed by saying that gold is more saleable than any other commodity. Silver is most marketable in the small. This can also be expressed by saying that silver, along with gold, is more hoardable than any other commodity. The Janus-face of marketability can be observed if we contemplate that gold is the preferred agent when one has to transfer value over space. The preferred agent in transferring value over time is silver followed by gold. We may clearly recognize the dual nature of money throughout history. In the ancient world money was cattle and salt. Cattle was most marketable in the large, while salt was most marketable in the small. Later two other commodities, far more similar to one another, took over these functions, but the dual nature of money has been maintained to this day, in spite of the silver and gold demonetization farce. This is no accident. Duality has to do with the paramount fact that space and time are absolute categories of human thought."
http://www.financialsense.com/…als/fekete/2007/0307.html
Sind die 9 Milliarden Unzen Silber, die seit WK 2 verbraten wurden, teilweise im sog. Silber-Carry-Trade, nunmehr von der Industrie verbraucht und als feiner Staub über den Planeten verteilt oder sind sie noch in Barren- und Münzenform vorhanden? Israel (Izzy) Friedmann wird nicht müde zu betonen, dass Silber knapp ist und irgendwann in die Shortage läuft. So geschehen wieder vorletzte Woche in seinem unnachahmlichen Slang:
"Author: izzy
Subject: Trading Air the metals. Number: 20762 :: Date/Time: 03-10-2007 :: 04:18
(…)
One think you have to undestand that the WORLD has GOLD suplay for the next 100 years, and in order to make GOLD as monitary invesment big changes has to be done, by the GOLD Consul!!!
SILVER is the only rare metal and we runnig aut of suplay in the future.People think that you have to buy big ammount of SILVER to have a chance to become rich??? Forgeted if I be right 1.000 ounce will settel a family for live. This chance you can\'t have in GOLD!!!
To invest in GOLD $13.000 and to have a chance to become rich???
Think that the moderen GOLD is SILVER!!!"
http://os2eagle.net/SSL/forum/index.php
Fekete hält dagegen und behauptet das genaue Gegenteil (im weiteren Fortgang des og. Artikels):
"The monetary metals are characterized by great stores above ground. The stock-to-flows ratio is a large multiple for gold. Silver analysts deny that the same holds for silver. They are at a loss to account for the disappearance of huge stockpiles of U.S. official silver in any other way but assuming that it has been dissipated through consumption. There is no hard evidence that this is indeed the case. We can account for the disappearance of monetary silver through a more plausible hypothesis, namely, that most of it has gone into hiding. It shall resurface at the right time and right price, as indeed some of it already has after the silver price hit a high of 15 dollars per ounce."
Die Preissfrage lautet nun: Wer liegt richtig, wer falsch? Fekete fährt fort mit seinen Ausführungen:
(...)
"Gold hoarding provides an escape for the individual from the harsh consequences of the predatory monetary and credit policies of the banks and the government as they plunge society into debt slavery. In the absence of the safeguards of a gold standard debt slavery is inevitable for those who fail to use the only prophylactic available: gold
(...)
The condition that obtains when the Futures price is above the spot, or the more distant futures price is above the nearby, is called contango and, the opposite, backwardation. Thus the basis is positive or negative according as the spot market is in contango or in backwardation. The prevalence of contango is a necessary condition for the warehousing business. Unless there is an expectation for contango to return after sporadic and temporary backwardation, warehousemen would go out of business and supplies for Future delivery would be all but unavailable.
The question arises what determines the basis. On the upside it is limited by carrying charges including freight, storage, insurance, and interest. In the case of gold and silver the lion’s share is interest. On the downside there is no limit: theoretically the basis can go negative and keep falling indefinitely. "
(…)
Er (Fekete) erklärt in vielen seiner nicht leicht zu lesenden Abhandlungen, dass der Zins das Bestechungsgeld ist, das Versprechen anstatt das Ding zu nehmen. Der Zins ist der Reif, der das Weltfinanzsystem ohne Goldstandard zusammenhält. Fällt der Realzins unter Null, wird das Ding genommen und das System ist bedroht. Contango und Backwardation haben bei den monetären Metallen Gold und Silber eine völlig andere Funktion als bei den übrigen Rohstoffen. Sie zeigen in diesem Fall nicht Knappheit/Überfluss an, sondern signalisieren, wie stark das System vom Absturz bedroht bzw. wie stabil es ist.
(...)
"The marginal bondholder who decides to sell his bonds in protest against low interest rates, and to invest the proceeds in gold, must not be depicted as Scrooge. He is a legitimate warehouseman who carries the hard core of social savings at a time when banks behave like drunken sailors on leave at the waterfront, and governments engage in compulsive overspending as if there was no tomorrow. The resulting capital destruction is appalling. After Armageddon no one but the warehouseman, alias gold investor, will be in the position to supply capital for reconstruction. Thank heaven for goldbugs. Without them we would have to go back and start from scratch as cavemen.
Backwardation can certainly occur, in particular, when supplies are drawn down just before the new crop of agricultural goods is ready to be brought in. However, backwardation for monetary metals is a gross anomaly, a red alert indicating potential breakdown of the payments system in the not-too-distant future.
(…)
Bull in bear’s skin
We must also exorcise the boogeyman of silver analysts: the naked short seller of monetary metals. The inordinate short interest in the futures markets is better explained in terms of the activities of a market maker whom I call ”bull in bear’s skin”. Typically, he is a super-wealthy individual who has learned the trick how to derive an income in gold on gold ─ even while retaining physical control over his holdings. He is not a naked seller by any stretch of the imagination. He does have the gold and silver, but keeps them at a safe distance from the commodity exchange and its predatory policies favoring the shorts at the expense of the longs. To his mind it pays to pose as a short. He hides his full armour underneath a mask showing him naked."
(...)
Sind die Short-Seller in Wirklichkeit Silber-Bullen im Bärengewand? Sind die hohen Shortbestände an COMEX und TOCOM gar nicht „naked”, sondern gedeckt durch über Jahrzehnte von den Short-Sellern akkumuliertes Silber (und Gold)? Und werden Sell-Outs in Papier-Silber von Zeit zu Zeit u.a. deswegen inszeniert, damit man billig an die Ware gelangt?
(...)
"Likewise, it is possible to harness the energy represented by the fluctuating price of gold and silver. The best way of doing this is to keep accumulating both monetary metals while maximizing the efficiency of hoarding. This means that one always buys the metal the hoarding of which is more efficient at the given price.
(...)
What to silver analysts appears as naked short selling is more likely the activities of bulls in bear’s skin. It is the tip of the iceberg that can be seen. What is not seen, the bulk of the iceberg, is dynamic hedging of ever increasing gold and silver hoards, and covered option writing, where the principal wants to stay anonymous. Needless to say the bull in bear’s skin is actually very happy that analyts believe, and spread the belief, that he is naked short. The longer he can keep his ”cover” as being ”naked”, the better it is for his operations.
It is futile and puerile to wait for the naked shorts to cover in a panic, sending the price through the roof. Cover yes, panic no. Make no mistake, this does not mean that the price may not go through the roof, but if it does, then it is also likely to go through the floor next time around when the pendulum swings back. It means that volatility is increasing. The get-rich-quick crowd, those who are ”insanely bullish on silver” waiting for the miracle of the silver price going to four digits overnight, will be frustrated. Rewards will go to the patient and industrious observer taking pains to study the market, and who has the right strategy that can handle the ever-increasing swings in the price both ways. He will not be dislodged from his long position when the pendulum swings back. He doesn’t subscribe to linear models. His guiding star is the non-linear model of the variation of basis.
Gold Standard University is working out a strategy following these principles, one applicable to small and big investors alike. It will be unveiled during the next session in August, 2007. At this point let’s just say that the strategy is essentially bimetallic arbitrage, but it uses the basis rather than the bimetallic ratio for clues."
(...)
Ist es für die Short-Seller im Moment effizienter, Akkumulation in Silber und Distribution in Gold zu betreiben als umgekehrt? Dafür spricht, dass die verfügbaren Bestände an Gold fünf mal höher liegen als diejenigen von Silber, hingegen Gold 50 mal höher notiert als Silber.
Wurde die ganze Silberstory um die „naked shorts” und die Butler-Rakete nur erfunden, um die horrenden physischen Silberbestände der Short-Seller zu vertuschen? Und sind Butler und Friedmann nur ganz kleine Rädchen im Räderwerk der Big Boys, die uns nicht alles sagen, was sie wissen?
Fragen, die mich bewegen und die mir bisher niemand beantworten konnte. Nicht mal Dosto’s hochkarätiger Silber-Thread 
Sonntagsgruß
Sil